Clay tile is the original Southwest roof. You see it on Spanish-style homes in the older parts of Phoenix, on custom homes in Scottsdale and Paradise Valley, and mixed in across the East Valley. From the street it looks a lot like concrete tile. It behaves a little differently, and it deserves a careful look.
Clay or concrete: how to tell
| Clay tile | Concrete tile | |
|---|---|---|
| Made of | Clay fired in a kiln | Cement, sand and water, cured |
| Color | Fired in, so it holds | Surface color fades and wears in the sun |
| Broken edge | Red or orange all the way through | Gray, with sand you can see |
| Common shapes | Two-piece mission (barrel), one-piece S, flat | Flat, low-profile, high-profile S |
| Underfoot | Brittle. Breaks easily when walked on | Tougher, but it still breaks |
The easiest check is a broken piece. If the inside is the same red-orange as the outside, it is clay. For more on the other kind, see my guide to concrete tile roofs.
Mission tile and S-tile
Two-piece mission tile is the classic look: rows of troughs (pans) with rounded caps (covers) laid over the joints. One-piece S-tile combines the pan and the cover into a single tile. Two-piece roofs have more pieces, more overlap and more places for a tile to slide out of position. On many of them the eave and ridge tiles are set in mortar, and that mortar cracks and lets go over time.
The underlayment is still the roof
Clay tile can last a very long time. The layer under it does not. Just like a concrete tile roof, the underlayment is what keeps the water out, and on an older home that is the part to ask about. I explain it in tile roof underlayment: the hidden bill on 20-year-old Arizona roofs.
For a sense of what a good tile roof calls for, the University of Arizona’s own building standards require heavy felt or a synthetic underlayment under clay tile on campus buildings. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance publishes the installation manual for both clay and concrete tile.
What I look for
- Broken and slipped tiles. Especially covers that have slid down and left the joint between two pans open. See broken or loose roof tiles.
- Open barrel ends at the eaves. Without bird stops, the round openings under the first row are an open door for pigeons, bats and roof rats. More in pack rats, roof rats and scorpions in the attic.
- Cracked or missing mortar at the ridges, hips and eaves.
- Debris in the valleys and pans. Water needs a clear path off the roof.
- Mismatched tiles, tar and patchwork. Signs of earlier leaks. Read why previous roof repairs concern me.
- Dried, cracked sealant at pipes and vents. See cracked roof penetration sealant.
- Stains in the attic and on ceilings. See water stains on roof sheathing.
- Sagging roof lines. Tile is heavy. See tile roof framing problems.
I am careful about walking clay tile. It breaks easily, and every broken tile is a new leak. A lot of my evaluation on these roofs comes from the edges, from a ladder, from the attic and from the ceilings inside.
Who to call
A licensed roofer with real clay tile experience. Not every roofer has it. Ask how they will handle broken tile and whether they can match what is on the roof. Check the license at the Arizona Registrar of Contractors, and look at the Arizona Roofing Contractors Association for members.
More Arizona building guides
Roofs: concrete tile, asphalt shingles and flat roofs. Walls and structure: stucco, slump block, concrete block and wood framing.
Home inspections in Gilbert and across Arizona
The roof, the attic and the ceilings below are part of every residential home inspection I do. Every home inspection includes a termite (WDO) inspection at no extra charge, and your report is delivered within 24 hours. We inspect homes in Gilbert, Scottsdale, Paradise Valley and across the Valley. See all of our service areas.
Buying a home? Book your inspection online or call 623-399-0079.


